Are Head Collars For Dogs Making Puppy Parents Lazy?

July 6, 2021
July 6, 2021

It’s a tough question at times, but what is the right way to use head collars? 

I see so many people using headcollars when walking their dogs around Basildon or Billericay. If you ask them, the most common reason is that their dog pulls and the headcollar stops them pulling. 

Is that right though? 

I’m not actually sure it is. It feels very much like we’re compromising our dogs comfort for our own aches. And that? That is never the way forward and rarely results in the right and desired outcome!

For context, I walk big dogs, lots and lots of big dogs. However, none of my dogs walk on a headcollar anymore. Why? Well, for me there are two main reasons;

  1. It’s not comfortable for the dog.
  2. It’s not necessary.

So, we’ve phased them out. Initially, if a dog comes to me on one, I’ll accept, but we usually phase it out quite quickly. To me? The headcollar is a symbol of laziness

Yep! Sorry if it offends, but I’ll explain! I promise, check through and hopefully you can see why I think that.

What are a dog head collars?

There is a range of headcollars for dogs, popular ones are Halti’s and Canicollars, a figure 8 and various others. 

The basic principle is that something on them tightens around the dog’s head or nose when they pull, which, in effect, takes the power out of your dog’s movement. In turn, this gives you back your control over a dog that’s pulling. It is an aversive training method, though, it is not quite in the same bracket as, say, a prong collar. 

Why do people use a headcollar? 

From my experience, this is because its “The only thing that stops their dog pulling”. Yep! It’s literally designed to do that. If I’ve ever asked further their dog won’t walk nicely on a lead, and they’ve ‘tried everything’. If you scroll through Facebook questions asking for help with their dog that pulls? This is such a common answer “Get a headcollar! Changed our lives”. And it will! For sure. But… is that what your dog deserves? Are you just switching the discomfort from you, to your dog?

NOTE: Something I have seen done – DO NOT EVER use one of these with a long line or flexi lead! If they come to a halt, you could snap a neck!! Please be careful!

white german shepherd wearing a head collar

Why don’t I like head collars?

They are an aversive training method. A gentle one, a fairly friendly one, but there is no escaping that they are an aversive training method. Consequently, I, as a lover of dogs, and a trainer (in training!) cannot support the use of these long term and especially not as the main way of controlling your dog.

Question – What is an Aversive Method?

Aversive method means a method in which something that applies unpleasant pressure or pain is applied to an animal to force them into an option that is desirable to their handler.

Typically, aversives result in your dog displaying other behaviours to counter it, a basic example is a puppy that gets shouted at for peeing on the carpet, so, it pees behind the TV instead. Puppy is doing the right thing in it’s head, because it’s just not allowed to pee on the carpet… You’re showing your dog what’s wrong to do, as opposed to what is right to do. 

We have a language barrier with our dogs, that much is obvious, but we have to guide them to what we want, and not tell them off for what we don’t want.

When is the right time to use a head collar?

In my opinion, there are TWO times when a headcollar is acceptable to be used;

1 – Training

When you’re training your dog to walk nicely on a lead? Absolutely acceptable to use it to aid teaching. It can be used to teach a dog how they are supposed to walk and slowly wean them off the headcollar and on to a harness or collar! Phase-out the headcollar eventually. Perfectly acceptable!

2 – Strong and/or high prey drive dogs

This one is slightly different, extremely high prey drive dogs who are likely to lunge or dart for their quarry are definitely great candidates for headcollars, and especially if they are powerful animals. Think Husky and Malamutes. Personally? I still passionately believe they can be trained, and Skye, our resident Malamute at Rove is complete proof!  But, so long as this is the back up for the owner and not the primary means of containing your dog – that I can understand.

puts on a halter on the golden retriever

How can you move off of a head collar?

Simple stuff. Grab a double-ended training lead (like a Halti training lead, it’s why they exist!) and attach one end to your dog’s headcollar, and one to their harness. Gradually change how you hold the lead over time (so you don’t lose their lovely loose lead walk that the headcollar has gifted you!) and if they’re doing good? Move your hand up the lead towards the harness. Eventually, try unclipping the headcollar and let them wear it loose. Then phase out altogether. They shouldn’t notice that it’s ‘gone’ and you should have imprinted how they should walk enough for them to do it without relying on the device.

So, does it make an owner lazy?

Usually? Yes.

I’m sorry! I’m not, but, hey… I genuinely believe every dog can be trained to walk nicely with time, patience and consistency. Sure, keep it on for back up, but it doesn’t need to be the sole reason your dog walks nicely.  Sure, they’re gentle (one is even called a gentle leader), but they can rub, they are definitely uncomfortable. Which means that the pet parent is choosing to take the easy route as opposed to persist in training.

Train! Please! I implore you. Train and be free of a headcollar! If you don’t know how, make sure to get advice from a force-free trainer, like those at the IMDT.

Husky Mix wearing a head halter outside

Don’t banish your dog to a life of headcollars!

What do I want you to take away from this? Well, I don’t want you to be angry, I want you to realise that you and your dog can be more. Training takes time, but it should be comfortable for both of you. It’s not a case that you have to pick which of you is in discomfort. You shouldn’t have an achey shoulder or back, and they shouldn’t have pressure put on their faces. Loose lead walking is totally doable! 

Please! You can totally do it. Every dog can be trained. With teaching, patience, and love, you can get them to heel or walk loose lead with great consistency. Don’t be lazy, you can do it! Sure, there will be days where it sucks, but there will be so many more where you and your dog are happy and comfortable walking around. 

Need some help doing this? Why not get in touch and we can totally discuss how to get you and your dog walking wonderfully together!  Or, if you know someone who needs this? Tag them on Facebook! And stay tuned, because we’re going to be coming out with a bunch of awesome Harness reviews and collars! 

 

You may also like

This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Please see our full disclosure for further information.

4 Comments

  1. Roni Krautheim

    I have an 8 month old Golden Retriever who not only pulls, but who jumps and lunges at people if we get too close. He’s not aggressive, he just wants to be near people and he never stops jumping on them if they het too close. He jumps with all 4 feet off the ground!

    The Halti is the only collar/harness that I’ve tried (and I’ve tried several) that gives me some measure of control. I use the doible ended lead with the head collar.

    We have been in training with the Halti for about 3 weeks now, and he will heel now as long as I have my treat pouch on. He will also sit or down on command as long as I continue to command and treat while someone else is near. So we are making progress.

    Halti has a process for weaning the dog off the headcollar, which is one of the reasons I decided to try it. Another reason is because the Halti is softer than the Gentle Leader, and doesn’t ride up his nose so easily. I’m looking forward to the day when he won’t need the Halti anymore, even if it takes several months to achieve.

    Reply
    • Ali Smith

      Hey Roni, it woiuld definitely have been achievable with a golden to train a loose leash without the headcollar. Please also be aware that jumping and lunging at people on a headcollar can do severe damage to neck and spine.

      Reply
  2. Mr Buddy Pets

    I read your above narration & realization that Head Collars are not important things for pet/dogs. It is not comfortable product for pet’s movement or other their activities but some times they need it just like training period, walking with their owner.
    Trained Dogs no need to use head collar.

    Reply
    • Ali Smith

      Absolutely true! Training is all it requires to get a good dog (unless the issue is medical)

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Related posts

5 Simple Ways To Help Your Fear Reactive Dog

5 Simple Ways To Help Your Fear Reactive Dog

Knowing where to start is always a pretty rough one when you have a fear reactive dog, but here are 5 ways that you can, very quickly, see a difference in your reactive dog. I've been a reactive dog parent, Indie (my german shepherd) developed reactivity during his...

read more
Rabbitgoo No-Pull Dog Harness – An Honest Review

Rabbitgoo No-Pull Dog Harness – An Honest Review

With lots of online lists recommending the Rabbitgoo Harness, you might be really tempted to invest in this harness for your dog. I know I was when I started looking at dog harnesses for Indie and things like 120k+ reviews on Amazon? Are really influential too. But is...

read more
Fleas & Your Dog – Everything You Could Need To Know

Fleas & Your Dog – Everything You Could Need To Know

Fleas are one of the most frustrating things you can deal with your dog. No one will disagree with that. Yet, spring is such a wonderful time of year! The sun is a little shinier, the sky is a little bluer, and the trees and flowers are bursting with colour. Just...

read more
True Love No-Pull Dog Harness – An Honest Review

True Love No-Pull Dog Harness – An Honest Review

Amazon is a wonderfully convenient place to pick up a dog harness, and True love is one of the most popular on the platform - especially seen as it's called "No pull" and has a handle - but how does it actually function? Harnesses are a great way to safely contain...

read more
Blue-9 Balance Harness – An Honest Review

Blue-9 Balance Harness – An Honest Review

When it comes to adaptable harnesses, the Blue-9 Balance harness is definitely up there. Harnesses are a really important part of how our dogs live their lives, so it's important that we get a harness that suits our individual dog, and that it fits appropriately. (A...

read more
​ ​