It’s hard to know when to spay or neuter – or if you should at all. Here’s the best veterinary advice for your Border Collie.
So you’ve decided to spay or neuter your Border Collie? – but when?
Often called getting your dog Fixed or Done (nomenclature that bugs me, because, fixed, implies broken, which is kinda mean!), the majority of dogs have this minor procedure performed upon them at a young age. Usually on a veterinary recommendation.
I know when Indie was little, I was told: “Six months, on the dot” – which is common advice given across America and Europe. If you ask the Internet (i.e. Facebook) usually recommendations say later and say a minimum of twelve months.
But is that even right? Or is it founded in any sort of science?
I know when Indie was little, I was told: “Six months, on the dot”
Ali Smith
With this conflicting information, how are you meant to know? Trust your vet? Do as your family has always done? Or trust the rando on the internet who appears to know it all.
None of that seems to be a good idea when the potential consequences of these procedures are rumoured to be some of the scariest diseases and ailments a dog can face… Cancer, Hip or Elbow Dysplasia, and other rotten afflictions like pyometra. All of this is the result of removing the availability of hormones…
Luckily, research has come forward which is not just size specific, but breed-specific for 35 breeds! So, here we’re going to discuss the ideal times for spaying or neutering your dog.
First, let’s do a little housekeeping…
What is Neutering?
This is the surgical castration of a male dog – usually by the removal of his testicles (sorry for making you cringe, gents!). This process means that your male dog cannot breed and that they are no longer producing hormones that are important to your dogs’ development – both emotionally and physically.
What is Spaying?
Similar to neutering, spaying is a form of surgical castration that removes the ovaries and most often the fallopian tubes along with it. This means your girl cannot breed, but it also means she is missing some critical hormones.
This process can be done in a ‘keyhole’ surgery at extra cost, though it is much better for recovery times.
So when is the best time for my Border Collie?
Recommended age:
Male – At least 1 year
Female – At least 1 year
Other than being slightly surprised at the relative lack of popularity of collies in this area, it’s great to see some uniformity in the recommendation across genders, but what is interesting is that the females – typically – see much more healthy generally!
I would also consider the fact that collies are often worked really hard, so these joint numbers may not be truly representative of the impact of the surgery, and more-so representative of how hard they were worked depending on the lifestyle choices of the collie. After all, I don’t know about you, but typically I see collies run into the ground with a ball very often and from a young age… the knowledge level of the pet parent may be equally or more influential in this instance.
But let’s explore that a little more…
What Are The Risks?
Here’s a quick overview of what the study says the breed suffers from depending on when their surgical castration (Spay or Neuter) was performed. The aim of providing this information is about giving you all the information to make the best decision.
Disorders include – Cranial cruciate ligament tears or ruptures, Hip Dysplasia, Elbow Dysplasia
Cancers include – Lymphoma, Hemangiosarcoma, Mast Cell Tumours, Bone Cancer (Osteosarcoma),
| Gender | Age of Surgical Castration | Disorder risk | Cancer Risk |
| Male | Under 6 months | 0% | 0% |
| Male | 6 to 11 months | 3% | 13% |
| Male | 12 to 23 months | 11% | 9% |
| Male | 2 years to 8 years | 0% | 4% |
| Male | Intact | 3% | 2% |
| Female | Under 6 months | 0% | 4% |
| Female | 6 to 11 months | 0% | 11% |
| Female | 12 to 23 months | 0% | 4% |
| Female | 2 years to 8 years | 0% | 4% |
| Female | Intact | 2% | 0% |
- For intact females, 4% reported Pyometra
- Urinary Incontinence was reported in just one qspayed female
- Mammary cancer was reported at 1% in intact females
- Mammary cancer was reported at 11% in females with spaying at 6-11 months
Look at these numbers for our girls! Wow! I think these are some of the healthiest numbers in the study, which is great to see.
What is interesting is that for both male and females, is that there is a large spike in cancer risks by performing these procedures in the 6-11 month window – which was the traditional suggestion.
By the reading of this, should I ever get a border collie? I would be looking at leaving them intact. Of course, these things are your decision.
So whilst this info is great for aiding, it should be considered as part of a much larger picture that only you can paint for your individual dog.
Are there other options?
If you’re doing what I am doing and looking at this research and reconsidering? It’s good to know that there are other options available.
Yes! On the presumption that these issues are caused by the lack of hormones (which is almost certainly the issue!) – there are a couple of ways to keep hormones but not facilitate breeding.
For Girls
Hysterectomy
This is the surgical removal of the uterus and only part of the fallopian tubes! The removal of these means that your girl is without the ability to breed – however – as she keeps her ovaries, hormones will still be produced and should mean that her risk levels are the same as an intact female – without the risk of pyometra! Though, there is a risk that the breeding instinct can remain? Which may be quite risky if a male tries to breed with her.
For Boys
Vasectomy
The tubes that run from the testes are called the vas deferens – these are what get cut or removed in this instance – rendering your dog without the ability to impregnate a female. It leaves his hormones (and likely his desire to breed as a result) but also means that your dog should have the same risk factors as an entire male.
Chemical Castration
Did you know that surgical castration is not legal in Norway? Consequently what is common in Sweden, Denmark, and Norway is chemical castration which is an injection your dog will have to have every six months that drop the levels of testosterone by approximately half. Which is proven to be effective in temporary neuter for your dog. This means you can actually test what castration might do to your dog and is often how it’s used in the UK and America – but it’s also a fantastic way of not putting your dog through surgical procedures.
About the Study
The study “Assisting Decision-Making on Age of Neutering for 35 Breeds of Dogs: Associated Joint Disorders, Cancers, and Urinary Incontinence” (Hart BL, Hart LA, Thigpen AP, Willits NH) was released in July 2020 – it covers 35 different breeds – and a separate scientific paper for mixed breeds. The study followed a total of 15,414 dogs over 15 years of recording;
- The age of the dog when neutered or spayed
- Breed
- Disorders including:
- Cranial cruciate ligament tears or ruptures
- Hip Dysplasia
- Elbow Dysplasia
- Pyometra (females only)
- Urinary incontinence (females only)
- Intervertebral disc disorders (Corgis & Dachshunds only)
- Cancers including;
- Lymphoma
- Hemangiosarcoma
- Mast Cell Tumours
- Bone Cancer (Osteosarcoma)
- Mammary Cancer (females only)
General Thoughts Across The Study
I find it incredibly interesting that there is breed-specific deviance. Prior to this, I was very much of the camp that it was simply a case of variations for dogs of different size brackets – but that appears not to be the case.
For example, a male Labrador (for whom I would have assumed were not dissimilar to Border Collies) actually have the best results when neutered at 6 months – yet the females prefer a slightly older age (When Should I Spay Or Neuter My Labrador is here by the way!).
So it’s really worth doing your research about these things.
As always? There’s not quite enough information to make a totally informed decision (yay for variables!) but, you can definitely get a good idea of it.
Other Considerations
It is worth noting that this study is a fantastic guideline – and one of the most solid pieces of research we’ve had – it doesn’t take into account many factors that I would imagine should be considered. The limitations I see are as follows;
- Multiple conditions were not recorded if they fell in the same category,
- Genetics were not considered,
- Living conditions were not considered,
- Food quality was not considered,
- The exercise a dog had was not considered,
- Body condition was not factored in because it had been studied previously and no strong correlation was found between body condition and joint issues.
The biggest thing I can say is, that whilst this is the scientific recommendation for when to spay or neuter your Border Collie do remember that at the end of the day? This is your decision. You are the only one who can make this decision. So, do your best – you’ve already found a phenomenal resource – just keep reading.
If you have any questions about spaying or neutering your Border Collie, drop them in the comments below! I’ll soon be doing a spay/neuter Frequently Asked Questions, which should help!
Author, Ali Smith
Ali Smith is a professional, qualified, and multi-award winning trainer is the founder of rebarkable. She has always believed animals deserve kindness and champions force free methods. Believing that dog guardians will all choose the kindest options if proper information is provided, she aims to help all dog guardians who need it and make dog training as accessible as possible
Ali lives win Maryland, US with her husband and her three dogs.
Thankyou. My girl is booked in just after 6 months. In Australia it is encouraged to do it before because council fees are cheaper 🙁 But I didn’t want to rush. Now I can rethink.
Totally understand, it’s an old mindset, but so long as you’re responsible? Getting the surgery at whatever age you think best, is always the answer
Thank you for putting this together. Very informative. I have a puppy male border right at 7 months and wanted to check on best time to neuter. Because of information I’ve gleaned, I think I will wait until he is at least 1 year.